Last Update
Image by OsloMetX from Pixabay

Tools

Affordable method of
measuring CO2

by titration using NaOH and phenolphthalein

Equipment

Required equipment → tools and chemicals

  1. NaOH 0.01 M solution
    • It can sometimes be difficult to obtain a 0.01 M solution. A 0.1 M solution is much more common. If only 0.1 M NaOH solution is available, prepare a more dilute 0.01 M version by measuring out 100 mL of 0.1 M NaOH, adding 900 mL of distilled water, and mixing thoroughly.
  2. Phenolphthalein 1% solution
    Chemicals
  3. Beaker 100 mL
    Beaker 100 ml
  4. Graduated syringe 1 mL
    • graduation interval: 0.01 mL (= 10 μL)
    • ideally with plastic pipette tip
    Graduated syringe 1 ml
Procedure

Procedure for determining the concentration of carbon dioxide in aquarium water

  1. Add 50 mL of aquarium water into a beaker.
  2. Add 2-3 drops of 1% phenolphthalein solution and mix the sample by gently swirling the beaker.
    • If the sample turns pink (and this color does not disappear after 30 seconds), then the sample does not contain any CO2, and there is no point in continuing.
  3. Draw exactly 1 mL of 0.01 M NaOH solution into the syringe.
  4. Carefully add the NaOH solution to the sample drop by drop from the syringe and mix the sample gently with a circular motion of the beaker after each drop.
  5. Once the sample turns a faint pink color (and this color does not disappear after 30 seconds), stop adding more drops of NaOH solution to the sample.
    Phenolphthalein #1
    Starting point
    Phenolphthalein #2
    Slow down
    Phenolphthalein #3
    Ending point
    Phenolphthalein #4
    Over shot
  6. Read the amount of NaOH consumed (in mL) from the syringe.
    • Let's refer to this amount as VNaOH
Explanation

Explanation the logic behind this method

  • CO2 makes water slightly sour (acidic).
  • You add a special dye (phenolphthalein) that's colorless in sour water.
  • You slowly drip in a strong soapy liquid (NaOH solution) until the water just barely turns pink.
  • The amount of soapy liquid you had to add tells you exactly how much CO2 was making the water sour in the first place.
Calculation

Calculation of the CO2 concentration

Formula:

CO2 (ppm) =
VNaOH × cNaOH × 44 × 1000
Vsample
  • VNaOH = Volume of NaOH solution used in the titration (in milliliters, mL)
  • cNaOH = Concentration of NaOH solution (in moles per liter, M) = 0.01 M
  • 44 = Molar mass of CO2 (in grams per mole, g/mol)
  • 1000 = Conversion factor (milligrams per gram, mg/g) AND (liters per milliliter factor for Vsample)
  • Vsample = Volume of your water sample (in milliliters, mL) = 50 mL

Example:

  • Let's say that I used 1.25 mL of 0.01 M NaOH to neutralize carbonic acid (H2CO3) in my 50 mL sample of aquarium water:
    CO2 =
    1.25 × 0.01 × 44 × 1000
    = 1.25 × 8.8 = 11 ppm
    50
  • So, I have 11 ppm of CO2 in my aquarium.

Alternative procedure with a smaller sample size (= 10 mL):

  • If I use a sample of aquarium water that is 5 times smaller (10 mL) but the same concentration of NaOH (0.01 M), I will logically have 5 times lower NaOH consumption (0.25 mL):
    CO2 =
    0.25 × 0.01 × 44 × 1000
    = 0.25 × 44 = 11 ppm
    10
  • However, the CO2 concentration in my aquarium should be the same: 11 ppm.
  • Note: This alternative method is less accurate.

Boxed edition

If you cannot find the above equipment or do not want to go to the trouble of finding it, you can buy it in the form of a ready-made kit from Hanna Instruments for $32.99.

For this price, you get:

  • 120 mL of NaOH (0.01 M)
  • 10 mL of Phenolphthalein (1%)
  • Two plastic containers (100 mL and 20 mL)
  • Graduated syringe (1 mL) with plastic pipette tip
Hanna HI3818
Hanna CO2 chemical test kit HI3818

Note:

  • In the attached instructions, Hanna uses rounded coefficients to calculate CO2 concentration:
    • For a 50 mL sample, the NaOH consumption should be multiplied by 10 (instead of the more accurate 8.8).
    • For a 10 mL sample, it should be multiplied by 50 (instead of the more accurate 44).
  • For this reason, the results given by this test will be slightly higher (compared to reality).
Back to Top